Rian’s Substack

Rian’s Substack

Case Study, It's not about who follows the rules best

Nothing is meant to be taken literally, except for what is

Rian Stone's avatar
Rian Stone
Feb 18, 2025
∙ Paid

This one is a simple case study of how to read and interpret what you’ve seen in the Red Pill. It may sound stupid, after all who can’t follow instructions? It’s not easy, it’s not simple, and guys have decades of gaslighting and brainwashing to overcome in order to literally RTFM. If you like my work, or want to support the channel, my books, or continued videos on the Red Pill, or simply want to read the field reports in depth, with the straight from the horses mouth part past the paywall, consider subscribing to the channel. It’s the price of a single coffee frap.

Is this worth the price of a single Starbucks coffee?

Introduction

Billy is reflecting on personal growth by experimenting with different approaches, particularly in fitness and relationships, to see what works. A major focus is distinguishing between validation-seeking sex and genuine intimacy, questioning whether rejecting his wife’s advances could provide clarity or unintended consequences. Ultimately, the message is about taking deliberate action, assessing outcomes, and applying praxeology to understand his true motivations rather than following rigid advice.

Advice isn't meant to be taken literally but to start a thought process, requiring interpretation and application to one’s own life. Communication operates on both content (what is said) and process (how it’s conveyed), with the latter being crucial yet often misunderstood—especially by those who take everything at face value. The key to growth is self-reflection, trial and error, and learning from mistakes rather than rigidly adhering to theories or seeking absolute truths.

Don’t be soft R artistic.

The problem with advice is that people might actually take it. Nothing you read here should be taken literally—except for the parts that should. But which is which? That’s for you to figure out.

It’s impossible to develop a comprehensive, literal, and precise theory of everything. I should know—I tried. The field reports, theories, mental models, and ideas in this praxeology will open your eyes, but they won’t do the heavy lifting in your life. What you read here, or anywhere in this space, should start a thought process, not end it.

In every conversation, there are two channels of information: open communication (the content) and closed communication (the process). Content is the literal meaning of the words—simple, direct, and easy to absorb for anyone who speaks English. It’s just the exchange of information, with no inherent agenda. Process, on the other hand, is the message conveyed through how I speak, what I do while speaking, what I assume you’ll take from my words, and how your biases shape your interpretation.

Process communication is the larger part of human language. This space is about using content to describe process—an unappealing, almost autistic way of discussing things. But even here, I can’t fully separate process from communication. No one can, because that’s not how people work.

Even now, the content isn’t the message—the end result isn’t just dry information. It’s about what you do with what you’ve learned, how you feel about it, your new state of mind, and hopefully, a change in action. There’s no way to encode that into words alone. I can describe you, but I can’t write you. Eventually, you’ll have to look at the different mental models here and interpret them within your own life.

Autists struggle to generalize, grasp implications, or understand subtlety and proportion. They take everything literally or reject it outright. They don’t see intent. Maybe this doesn’t apply to you, but if it does, you’ll need to develop this skill before anything here—or from anyone—will be useful to you. Women communicate primarily through process, so maybe the same issues men have with the Red Pill are related to the issues they have with women.

I can’t just tell you—I have to show you. Through example, story, allegory, and essay. And you have to figure out how to be shown.

  • If you argue about whether literally all women are like that…

  • If you treat everything as a shit test…

  • If you focus on the tone being off-putting rather than the message…

  • You’re being autistic.

Stop.

Instead, use your social skills to read between the lines. Think about the presentation. Think about the process. Use your own brain.

The field report is simple but illustrates this point exactly. The guy takes everything he hears and applies it hyper-literally. If he sounds familiar, it’s because he is. He’s the same guy from

Case Study: Self Improvement navel gazing

Rian Stone
·
February 11, 2025
Case Study: Self Improvement navel gazing

Self Improvement

Read full story

Last one, I promise

The Dog Walker launch has been amazing, better than anyone could have hoped for! The Nonsense-Free Editor did a piece on the subject and themes of the book, and also how it places itself in a world that doesn’t write fiction for men anymore. It’s worth a watch!

The book has already sold 125 copies over the weekend, which is almost tied with Frame, the currently best selling of all my books. I cannot thank you guys enough and know that each of you will enjoy it. Everyone has been saying the same two things:

I wasn’t expecting this at all

It’s really good. I mean it’s actually, really good. I laughed, a lot

It has one hurdle, in that there are no books on the market that I can find that match it’s themes, energy and genre. At least not any that aren’t written for women, by women, and about women. So do me a favor, if you’ve read it, leave a review on either goodreads or Amazon. Even if you don’t like it, just be honest. I don’t want anyone to be surprised by what they are in for!

Get yours here!

Get yours here!


Continued

I’m not shitting on him because I think he’s doing something wrong. The reason I’m including him here is that this process isn’t easy. Some guys have built their entire lives on fantasies—the feminine imperative, a geocentric social order, religious gaslighting, etc. If fixing it were as simple as reading an essay and applying it, there’d be no need for field reports. It would be intuitive.

But it’s not—and that’s okay. That’s normal.

What matters is self-reflection. In this case, he’s wrong, but at least he’s started the process. He’s no longer being autistic about it, and that’s a good thing.

Mistakes will be made. Feelings will be hurt. Sex will be missed out on.

But as long as he learns, it’ll work itself out.

I’ll let you judge whether he’s still listening like an autist or if he’s finally starting to get it—or at least screwing up in new ways that will eventually lead him there.

Billy, reflected

I lifted three times following my existing routine.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Rian Stone.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Rian Stone · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture